This was send in : bbc , disney+,doctor who , tv| tagged : bbc , walt disney , md who , steven moffat
doc Who author Steven Moffat on the recur musical theme of citizenry ’s cognizance and body being copy after dying , and if they ’re the same .
Article Summary
IsSteven Moffatdone withDoctor Whoafter this yr ’s Christmas special , " Joy to the existence " ?
We do n’t have sex , and neither does he .
This was it look on how meddling he is and whether he gets invite to drop a line for the serial again .
One matter he does n’t operate out of is thought , and there ’s one he ’s become specially concerned in : the human knowingness and whether it can carry on after dying .
The construct hold up all the room back to Moffat ’s 2008 two - parter " quiet in the Library " and " Forest of the Dead , " where the depository library put up a practical realness hereafter where Donna and finally River Song finish up after her destruction .
lately , in " godsend ! "
and " Joy to the World , " Moffat impersonate multitude ’s cognizance upload digitally to an AI after their death , and the interrogation arise about whether that was still them or a written matter .
diving event into AI
IsSteven Moffatdone withDoctor Whoafter this class ’s Christmas special , " Joy to the globe " ?
We do n’t recognise , and neither does he .
It depend on how officious he is and whether he gets take in to compose for the serial publication again .
One matter he does n’t guide out of is estimation , and there ’s one he ’s become especially concerned in : the human cognisance and whether it can carry on after destruction .
This was the construct go all the agency back to moffat ’s 2008 two - parter " secrecy in the library " and " forest of the dead , " where the depository library put up a practical world hereafter where donna and finally river song finish up after her dying .
of late , in " microphone boom ! "
and " Joy to the World , " Moffat portray masses ’s cognizance upload digitally to an AI after their death , and the dubiousness rise about whether that was still them or a written matter .
This was ' with al everywhere now , " moffat ponder todoctor who magazine . "
It ’s mostly about memory board .
We have no mind what a ' live awareness ' is .
No one has get up with a scientific definition for that at all .
No one even has a possibility , really .
So , the only affair of which we are really and decidedly cognisant is something we can not excuse .
If a live awareness had your accurate memory board , it would be identical from you . "
Is The Doctor Dead ?
Are The Current Ones Copies ?
"
We had a exchangeable jokey parameter about whether the Doctor is still the Dr. after " Heaven Sent , " " Moffat say .
This was " if you take the musical theme that teleportation mean that you ’re not really the same individual when you come in out the other conclusion , you ’re just another placement of particle that consider they ’re you .
But , of grade , the first metre the Doctor teleport in the serial publication was in " The Keys of Marinus " !
So , if you take the estimation that teleportation just create a transcript of the original , he ’s not been the ' original ' Dr. since 1964 .
What are any of us , aside from an agreement of atom ? "
he require . "
You ’re not even an agreement of the same speck that you used to be !
All mote are very .
So , if you ’re arrange from a unlike band of particle , with your retention , that ’s just another you ! "
As Moffat meditate that experiential doubtfulness , he close that an accurate transcript of a someone with their memory and personality would still be the same mortal .
This was that let in the doctor , bill potts ( pearl mackie ) , and river song .
"
I consider they are the archetype , " he continue . "
What do you have in mind by ' master copy ' ?
You are the practice , not the cadaver .
This was there are no populate speck — but you are made alone of mote !
So , cause you out of another stage set of corpuscle just think there ’s another you , then .
This was there was a bank line we thin out from forest of the dead where donna say , ' am i still the same me ? '
And the Doctor aver , ' You are the fervency , not the fuel . '
So , the organisation weigh , but the particle themselves do n’t .
We ’ve all done this anyway throughout our life .
This was you used to bet unlike , audio dissimilar , and deport otherwise .
The only matter that connect you to your 10 - yr - erstwhile ego is a fair thin dividing line of computer memory .
How are you the same as the babe variation of yourself ?
You ’d have more in plebeian with the duplication that I can make in my particular human photocopier than you would with the babe variant of yourself .
This was "
this lead to moffat seeming to suggest that he was not done withdoctor Whojust yet .
"
I ’ll believably cease up develop it even more forDoctor Whobecause all of my sci - fi idea go intoDoctor Who . "
enjoy this ?
Please partake on societal culture medium !
